I'm excited to share some fascinating insights and results from my recent teaching experiences at Butler University. This past academic year has been both a challenge and a revelation as I ventured into teaching new courses on personal finance. Here's what I've discovered.
Unveiling the Classes: One Credit vs. Three Credit
I recently compared two different formats of personal finance classes: a one-credit Financial Well-Being class and a three-credit Personal Finance class. Our goal? To understand which class format truly resonates with students, equipping them effectively for real-world financial decisions.
Engagement and Applicability
Interestingly, our findings revealed that 97.4% of students in the one-credit class found the course highly engaging, versus 92% in the three-credit version. Further, almost equivalent percentages believed they could apply what they learned: 93.5% in the one-credit and 88% in the three-credit class.
Preparedness and Behavioral Change
As educators, our mission is to foster financial preparedness and inspire change. In both classes, approximately 75% of students felt more prepared to manage their finances, and a majority expressed plans to alter their financial behaviors immediately. Notably, the one-credit course seemed slightly more effective in this area.
Confidence and Satisfaction
Confidence is key in financial decision-making. Here, results were intriguing: 62% of one-credit participants reported increased confidence, contrasted with 48% in the three-credit class. This surprisingly suggests that less may indeed be more effective in building financial confidence. Both courses had high satisfaction rates, with nine out of ten students recommending them.
Exploring Student Demographics and Learning Formats
We also examined outcomes across different student demographics, finding that both business and non-business majors reported similar levels of engagement and knowledge improvement. Additionally, online and face-to-face learning formats surprisingly showed comparable, if not higher, engagement and preparedness results.
Rethinking Traditional Education
The overarching theme of our results suggests a shift away from traditional, information-heavy courses towards focused, behavioral-based learning. This approach aligns with growing acceptance in the academic community for curricula that link learning directly to behavioral change, rather than merely imparting knowledge.
Conclusion: Embracing Simplicity in Financial Education
At its core, the challenge is balancing information with actionable guidance. My teaching experience has highlighted the potential effectiveness of providing students with a streamlined, direct approach to financial education. As educators, prioritizing simplicity and behavioral teaching may very well lead to a more impactful learning experience.
Join the Conversation
As I continue to refine these courses and share insights, I encourage you to reach out with any questions or thoughts. There's much more to explore in the realm of personal finance education, and I'm eager to engage with educators and students alike on this journey.
Created with
